The Church Fathers on this verse

2 Kingdoms (2 Samuel) 16:10Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

And the king said: What have I to do with you, ye sons of Sarvia? Let him alone and let him curse: for the Lord hath bid him curse David: and who is he that shall dare say, why hath he done so?

Douay-Rheims

וַיֹּ֣אמֶר הַמֶּ֔לֶךְ מַה־לִּ֥י וְלָכֶ֖ם בְּנֵ֣י צְרֻיָ֑ה כי כֹּ֣ה יְקַלֵּ֗ל וכי כִּ֤י יְהוָה֙ אָ֤מַר לוֹ֙ קַלֵּ֣ל אֶת־דָּוִ֔ד וּמִ֣י יֹאמַ֔ר מַדּ֖וּעַ עָשִׂ֥יתָה כֵּֽן׃

Hebrew (Masoretic text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

7 Church Fathers comment on this verse · 9 commentaries

John Chrysostom

4th centuryChurch Father

The Scriptures remind us, ‘Remember, O Lord, David and all his meekness’ (Psalm 131:1). In the face of Semei's scornful mockery and insults during his time of distress, David displayed remarkable wisdom in his words.

Nonetheless, David also transgressed, yet we must consider his path to repentance. For three days he remained in humility, not seeking forgiveness for his own wrongdoing, but pleading for the life of his ailing child, who had yet to recover. David’s path of repentance took on another form: he demonstrated deep humility, a contrite heart, sorrowful spirit, and rigorous avoidance of future sins. He continually reflected on his transgressions, patiently enduring the trials he faced while extending mercy toward his offenders.

Read more (222 words)

Crucially, not only did he refrain from seeking vengeance for the insults he received, but he also prevented others from retaliating on his behalf. When Semei unleashed a torrent of curses upon him, and David's commander felt indignation, David simply replied, ‘Let him curse, for the Lord has commanded him to curse David.’ His heart was contrite and humble, serving as a true balm for his transgressions, for this is the essence of confession and repentance. In contrast, should we fast while harboring arrogance, it will lead us not to benefit but to our detriment. Therefore, humble your heart to appease God: ‘The Lord is near to the brokenhearted’ (Psalm 33:19).

Consider how those who lived in splendor endured dishonor; even when insulted by their servants, they chose not to retaliate but bore the shame of their transgressions. Let us emulate their example. If you are reviled, resist the temptation to harden your heart; rather, mourn and lament—not for the outrage suffered, but for the sins that have led to such dishonor. Mourn not merely for fear of punishment, for that is inconsequential, but for having offended your gracious Master, who loves you dearly and desires your salvation to the extent of offering His Son on your behalf. This should be your constant lament, as it embodies the true spirit of confession.

Augustine of Hippo

5th centuryChurch Father

Through this patient endurance, we find strength even during periods of good health, as our authentic joy is often postponed amid the trials of this world. It was through such patience that St. David withstood the slurs of the Benjamite who spoke ill of him. Although he had the power to retaliate and could have easily expressed his hurt, he chose not to seek revenge. When he observed others harboring vengeful thoughts against the aggressor, he exercised his royal authority to prevent retribution rather than to carry it out. In that moment, he did not suffer from physical injuries or ailments; instead, he recognized the season of humility and embraced it as the Lord's will. Consequently, he bore the bitter chalice of humiliation with profound patience and gentleness.

Basil the Great

4th centuryChurch Father

The restless and irrational stirrings of the heart ought to be calmed by reflecting on the lives of holy individuals. Consider how patiently the great David endured the insults of Semei. He did not allow anger to take root but instead focused his thoughts on the Lord, believing that ‘The Lord speaketh to Semei to curse David.’ Thus, when confronted with the labels ‘the man of blood and the man of iniquity’ (2 Sam. 16:7), he did not respond with irritation towards Semei; rather, he humbled himself, accepting the wrongs he was facing as if they were warranted.

Ambrose of Milan

4th centuryChurch Father

What is the purpose of feeling sorrow when we encounter scorn? Why should we not follow the example of the one who proclaimed, I was the one who was humbled and silent, who refrained from speaking even of good things (Psalm 38:3)? Is it true that David merely spoke these words without embodying them? Absolutely not; he lived by them. When Shimei, the son of Gera, insulted David, he chose silence; despite the presence of soldiers around him, he neither retaliated against the abuse nor sought vengeance. Even when the son of Zeruiah suggested that David deserved death, he forbade any such action. Unmoved and voiceless, he remained calm, indifferent even to being labeled a bloodthirsty man, as he was fully aware of his own humility.

Read more (78 words)

The slanders did not disturb him, for he was conscious of his many virtuous acts. A person who quickly reacts to injustice often appears as one deserving of insult, even if that is not their true intent. It is far better for one to dismiss injustice than to endure it; for one who dismisses it views it with disdain as if untouched by it, while one who bears it suffers deeply, as if they genuinely feel its weight.

We must also be cautious of those who provoke us, those who aggravate and harden hearts, and those who promote immorality and desire. When we face insults, irritations, harassment, and incitements to conflict, it is wise for us to hold our tongues. It is not disgraceful to be silent; rather, it is sinful for those who would instigate and offend us, striving to bring us down to their level, as noted in Proverbs 26:4.

Read more (491 words)

Should we choose to remain quiet and unresponsive, the offender may taunt us, saying, "Why are you silent? Speak up if you are brave enough!" They might believe they have silenced us, enlarging their fury further, convinced they have emerged victorious and ridiculed us. On the other hand, if we reply, they will feel triumphant, having drawn us into their conflict. However, if we choose silence, witnesses may say, “He was insulted, but he disregarded the insult.” When we reply with accusations, it only leads to mutual reproach, leaving both parties condemned without justification. My accuser aims to provoke my anger, enticing me to react as they have. A righteous person will ignore this, remaining mute and steadfast, as they value the judgment of virtuous souls over the mockery of the accuser, buoyed by their integrity, as Cicero aptly remarks.

This silence regarding even matters of virtue, as expressed in Psalm 38:3, indicates that one who knows their righteousness will not tremble before spurious allegations, prioritizing their inner truth over another's accusations, thereby embracing humility.

If an individual wishes to avoid humiliation, they may reason in this fashion: “My accuser scorns and slanders me as if I am without voice. Why should I remain silent in the face of such disdain? What makes them believe I cannot defend myself? They presume I cannot retaliate!”

One who speaks in this manner lacks meekness and humility, fearing temptation’s grasp. The tempter fuels their spirit with such thoughts, typically influencing them through a third party, instilling an unholy spirit into their heart. Yet we must remain steadfast, anchored upon the rock referenced in Matthew 16:18. Even if a slave or a weak person hurls insults, the righteous will keep their peace; even when faced with reproach from a beggar, they will not retaliate. The righteous wield the strength of retreat, conquering as expert warriors do—by withdrawing to inflict greater wounds on their assailant, as discussed in Epistle 57:12.

Why do we respond with indignation when we encounter reproach? Why do we not emulate the one who declared, “I am numbed and humbled; I am silent even regarding good things” (Psalm 38:3)? Did David merely articulate this sentiment without embodying it? Certainly not; he exemplified it. When insulted by Shimei, as described in 2 Samuel 16:5, David remained silent in the face of accusation, accompanied by soldiers but choosing not to retaliate or seek vengeance. When advised by his companion to punish Shimei, David refrained, embodying humility by remaining silent like a mute and steadfast in his meekness, undisturbed by harsh words. He knew his history was filled with good deeds, rendering insults impotent.

A person who rushes to respond to injustice only affirms the accusations they wish to deny. Thus, one who disregards an offense possesses greater strength than the one suffering it; the one who neglects the offense appears unconcerned, while the one who endures it visibly bears the weight of the insult.

We can demonstrate that St. David exemplified the same virtue of humility as St. Paul. Initially, when the son of Semeiah insulted him, it was rooted in David's awareness of his own righteous deeds, as noted in Psalms 38:3. In his response, David chose to endure the reproach, understanding that through such suffering he could receive God's mercy. Observe how David embodied humility, justice, and wisdom in his pursuit of the Lord's favor. He declared, “Therefore he speaketh evil, because the Lord commanded him to speak evil” (2 Samuel 16:10). This reflects his humility; he perceived himself as a servant obligated to execute the divine directive.

John Cassian

5th centuryChurch Father

Regardless of the origin of anger's spark, it dims the heart's vision, covering our ability to see clearly and hindering our perception of the brilliance of truth. Whether a thin layer of gold, lead, or any other metal is placed upon our eyes, the material's worth does not alter its capacity to obscure sight. Yet, from anger comes a beneficial service when we find ourselves troubled by the seductive impulses of our hearts. We can recognize this discomfort as it arises within us, prompting feelings of shame when we consider acting or speaking in ways unworthy before others. We tremble at the realization of an all-seeing presence, aware that God and His angels witness even our most hidden thoughts.

Read more (204 words)

When we become indignant against our own anger, questioning its intrusion and the way it provokes discord among our brethren, we can reject its harmful suggestions, refusing to let them dwell in the private corners of our hearts where they could cause harm. The Prophet exemplifies this righteous anger, having resolutely cast off such passions to the point that he would not seek vengeance against those who openly opposed him, even when divinely delivered into his power.

For instance, when Shimei hurled stones at King David and cursed him, Abishai the son of Zeruiah sought to punish this insult. Yet, the blessed David, filled with righteous indignation at Abishai's suggestion, remained steadfast in his humility and patience. He replied, "What have I to do with you, you sons of Zeruiah? Let him curse, for the Lord has told him to curse David. Who then shall say, 'Why have you done this?' For my own son, who came from my own womb, seeks my life, and how much more now this Benjamite? Let him alone and let him curse, for the Lord has commanded him. It may be that the Lord will look upon my affliction and repay me with good for his cursing today."

Gregorios Palamas

14th centuryChurch Father

David exemplified that one who sees themselves as guilty before God and seeks repentance must endure the rightful and bearable insults and shame from others. After he had sinned, upon hearing Shimei's reproaches, he instructed those who wished to take vengeance on his behalf, “Leave him alone; let him curse, for the Lord has commanded him to curse David.” This indicated that, by permitting Shimei to speak ill of him, David recognized it as a directive from God. At that moment, David was facing a profound and grave trial, as Absalom had risen up against him.

John of Tobolsk

17th centuryChurch Father

The righteous king, chosen by God on three distinct occasions, when confronted by his unscrupulous subject—who had no cause for offense by either word or action—did not respond with anger nor project a terrifying demeanor. Rather than seeking retaliation for the insult, he took on the role of a protector of his accuser, urging his companions, “Leave him alone; let him revile, for the Lord has commanded him to speak against David. Who can question this?” He recognized in the scorn directed at him the allowance of God’s will. While Semei may have committed a grave sin in his cursing, it was ultimately God who used him as a vessel for this revilement; He was not the originator of Semei's malice but rather employed him as a means of discipline for David.

Read more (177 words)

In a similar manner, each of us should view the attacks and slanders from wicked individuals, whose unruly intentions are employed by our merciful God to either instruct the innocent or chastise the guilty. Such trials serve as a corrective rod for our transgressions or as a restraint to deter us from sin. Hence, anyone unjustly criticized or wronged should echo David's plea before the Lord, “Lord, I refuse to repay evil with evil. I do not wish to retaliate against my opponent; I leave vengeance to You: the Lord lives! Let the Lord strike him down, or his moment will come, and he will perish in battle” (1 Sam. 26:10). Therefore, we ought to elevate our resolute hearts in acknowledgment of God's providence. If our adversaries conspire against us with cunning plans, there is no need to be afraid. The righteous are under God’s protection, who assures us that we are precious in His sight: “concerning you touches the apple of My eye” (Zech. 2:8). Those who are upright in heart need not dread their foes.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.