The Church Fathers on this verse

Job 21:19Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

God shall lay up the sorrow of the father for his children: and when he shall repay, then shall he know.

Douay-Rheims

אֱל֗וֹהַּ יִצְפֹּן־לְבָנָ֥יו אוֹנ֑וֹ יְשַׁלֵּ֖ם אֵלָ֣יו וְיֵדָֽע׃

Hebrew (Masoretic text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

3 Church Fathers comment on this verse

John Chrysostom

4th centuryChurch Father

After Sophar, who had spoken earlier, asserted that these events have persisted since humanity's creation (Job 20:4), Job challenges him for failing to grasp the evident truth. He states, "You claimed that these occurrences are consistent, yet the reverse is also true. Hence, no one should assume they comprehend the divine purpose by which all things come to pass. Indeed, I ask you: if those individuals are not evil, why do they face judgment? One is in need while another thrives, despite their shared wrongdoing."

Gregory the Great

6th centuryChurch Father

God shall impose upon the children the sorrow of their father. When He administers justice, he will recognize it, as stated in Job 21:19. We also understand from Scripture, "For the guilt of the fathers He punishes the children, and the children’s children to the third and fourth generation" (Ex. 34:7). Additionally, it is written, "Why do you use this proverb in the land of Israel, saying, ‘The fathers ate sour grapes, and the children have splinters in their teeth’? As I live!’ declares the Lord God, ‘You will not say this proverb in Israel. For behold, all souls are Mine: as the soul of the father, so the soul of the son is Mine; the soul that sins shall die" (Ezekiel 18:2-4).

Read more (585 words)

In these two declarations, while there is a multiplicity of meanings, the listener must seek understanding through discernment. We inherit original sin from our parents, and unless we receive the grace of Baptism that liberates us from it, we carry the weight of our parents’ sins. Thus, when it is said that "He chastises the children for the fault of the fathers," it refers to how the offspring’s soul is tainted by original sin due to the parents' failings. Conversely, He does not "lay the sins of the fathers upon the children," for with Baptism, we are released from the original guilt, and only bear the sins for which we are personally responsible.

This can also be interpreted in another way: those who emulate the sinful paths of their parents become entangled in their sins. However, those who do not mimic their parents’ wrongdoing are not bound to them in their transgressions. Therefore, it is said that a wicked son, by following a wicked father, is accountable not just for his own added sins but also for the sins of his father. His awareness of his father's actions, which anger the Lord, does not deter him from compounding his own iniquity. This illustrates that one who chooses to follow an evil parent will have to answer for the misdeeds of both themselves and their ancestors. Consequently, it is stated, "As the soul of the father, so also the soul of the son is Mine; the soul that sins shall die," as the father's sin can indeed lead to the son’s destruction.

However, if original sin has been removed, those children are no longer linked to the sins of their parents. This raises the question of why, then, do infants frequently experience demonic afflictions, and why do the innocent suffer for the wrongdoings of their fathers? A sinful father, being too stubborn to recognize his own faults, often sees his own punishment amplified through his children, where the sorrow of the father manifests in the flesh of his offspring. When it is the older descendants who are punished for their parents' sins, it clearly indicates that they are being held accountable for the deeds they imitate. Thus, it is fitting to say, "even to the third and fourth generation." As it is feasible for children to emulate the life of their wicked ancestor, that same accountability extends to those who observe and mimic their actions.

Moreover, since sin blinds the wicked, while suffering opens their eyes to past transgressions, this leads to the conclusion: "And when He repays, he shall know it." The wicked often remain unaware of their evil actions until they begin to experience the consequences of those actions. This aligns with the prophet's words, "And one vexation will give understanding to what he hears" (Isaiah 28:19). It is only when he faces grief for his negligence that he starts to grasp what he has heard. Balaam also expressed, "He that hath heard the words of God, who seeth the visions of the Almighty, who shall fall, but his eyes shall be opened" (Num. 24:3-4). The chosen ones have foresight, ensuring they do not sin, thus their eyes are truly open. In contrast, the wicked only open their eyes following their downfall, as it is through their punishment that they recognize what they should have avoided and the wrong they have committed. The profound insight that comes to this individual, which ultimately serves no purpose for him, is captured in the words that follow.

Ireneus (Orda)

19th centuryCommentator

Job no longer seeks solace from his companions; rather, he desires their silence so he can fully express his grievances regarding his anguish (21:1-6). Their attempts to illustrate the downfall of the wicked following brief periods of joy are futile, as numerous cases exist where the wicked live and die in happiness (7-13). They dismiss divine Providence (14-15); the prospect of sudden death does not intimidate them (16-18), nor does the unfortunate fate of their descendants trouble them (19-21). Who can, in light of this, dictate to God the criteria for the distribution of joy and sorrow among humanity (22)? Before God, both the wicked and the righteous face the same end (23-26). Only Job's companions believe that the wicked are destined for ruin (27-28).

Read more (99 words)

Yet experience reveals that the wicked enjoy both life and a peaceful death (29-33). Thus, Job concludes that their reasoning lacks any solid foundation (34).

During this part of the dialogue, Job's friends transition from vague hints of Job's hidden sins to outright accusations of hypocrisy and pride. They maintain their earlier belief in the unavoidable retribution against wickedness, threatening Job with dire consequences. In contrast, Job increasingly asserts his innocence and challenges the validity of his friends' views, attributing the fortunes and misfortunes of individuals to the mysterious workings of divine Providence, rather than to one's moral standing.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.