The Church Fathers on this verse

Psalm 78 (77):29Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

So they did eat, and were filled exceedingly, and he gave them their desire:

Douay-Rheims · Hebrew numbering, Septuagint numbering in brackets.

וַיֹּאכְל֣וּ וַיִּשְׂבְּע֣וּ מְאֹ֑ד וְ֝תַֽאֲוָתָ֗ם יָבִ֥א לָהֶֽם׃

Hebrew (Masoretic text)

The Church Fathers on this verse

8 Church Fathers comment on this verse

Augustine of Hippo

5th centuryChurch Father

That is the reason for His delay. Let us explore what He postponed. The consequence was within their grasp, and God's wrath descended upon them (Psalm 77:30). Observe what He withheld. He first delayed, and as a result, a fire ignited in Jacob, and His anger was stirred against Israel. Thus, He chose to delay in order to accomplish what they believed was impossible for Him, subsequently allowing them to face the consequences they deserved. Had they placed their trust in God, not only would their earthly desires have been fulfilled, but their spiritual longings would also have been satisfied. The One who opened the gates of Heaven and showered manna upon those who lacked faith possesses the ability to grant believers the true Bread from Heaven, which that manna represented.

Read more (157 words)

This Bread, the sustenance of angels, is incorruptibly provided by the Word of God. To enable humanity to partake in this sustenance, He took on flesh and dwelt among us (John 1:44). The Bread Himself, through the clouds of the Gospel, is spread throughout the world; the hearts of the preachers act as heavenly portals, proclaiming the message not to the contentious and testing synagogue but to the Church, which believes and places its hope in Him. Additionally, He can strengthen the faith of those who believe without being tempted, offering them signs in the words articulated by flesh and carried through the air, akin to birds of a different origin—not the cold and foggy North, representing worldly eloquence that may please but does not satisfy. Instead, He brings the warmth of the South Wind from Heaven, nurturing those with fragile faith who, captivated by earthly matters, are prepared to receive the gifts of the heavenly realm.

Ephraem the Syrian

4th centuryChurch Father

Do not cloak yourself in weakness, O monk, when you are in good health, for it is said, 'and their desire shall be brought to them'

Theodoret of Cyrus

5th centuryChurch Father

They indulged in their desires and fulfilled their greed; yet they faced consequences for their unquenchable appetite.

Euthymios Zigabenos

11th centuryCommentator

Moses writes in Numbers, "And a wind went up from the Lord, and brought quails from the sea, and scattered them about the camp" (Num. 11:31). David notes that God separated the winds into the east and south, signifying the warmer regions where such winds blow and where these birds can be found. Instead of the phrase "stirred up," the term "rose" is used. The expression "wept" indicates that the quails were carried through the skies as abundantly as rain. Their vast numbers were compared to the dust and sand of the sea, as they were so plentiful that they satisfied the hunger of six hundred thousand five hundred sixty people for an extended period. "A whole month, it is said, you shall eat until it comes out of your nostrils" (Num. 11:20).

Read more (406 words)

The count of those fit for battle was mentioned for those twenty years and older, excluding the younger generation, women, and the entire tribe of Levi. In the center of the camp and surrounding each tent, God provided manna so that it would be easy to gather. The term "camp" refers to the community of people in the wilderness, while "dwellings" denotes each individual’s tent. When it is said, "Their desire brought them," it implies that they received from God all that they longed for, achieving the fulfillment of their wishes. God granted them what they sought; thus, the term "desire" is substituted for what they yearned for, akin to how the Apostle Paul uses "hope" to signify the attainment of what he longed for, as expressed in "Hope shall not be ashamed." Subsequently, the anger of God was kindled against them, resulting in the death of many among the elect of Israel. As they beheld the quails, they failed to trust God's promise that they would be satisfied with these birds by the month's end, fearing they might escape or spoil. Consequently, they "dried them for themselves round about the camp," and while the meat was still in their mouths, the Lord's anger was ignited against the people, leading to a severe plague (Num. 11:33). It is notable that as soon as they swallowed the meat, they lost their faith and forgot God's might. Thus, their desires were fulfilled as a testament to divine power and providential care; however, due to their disbelief and insatiable appetites, what was meant to nourish them turned into a cause of devastation, leading to much death, as Moses noted. The phrase "the greatest of them" was translated by Simmachus as "fat" and by Aquila as "rich," suggesting the wealthiest and strongest among the people. It is likely that those who collected more fell victim to the plague in greater numbers. Nevertheless, Aquila and Symmachus reached this interpretation based on further context, as many among the chosen of Israel were likewise affected. The interpreters used the term "most numerous" not to compare the dead to the survivors but to emphasize the sheer number. This aligns with Moses' statement that "The Lord smote the people with a very great plague," a phrase indicating the death of many. They were referred to as "chosen," as they were valiant in battle; those counted were all capable warriors and, for this reason, were selected.

Hesychius of Jerusalem

5th centuryChurch Father

Consider the scenario of an immense crowd, gluttonous in nature, being nourished not just for a single day but for a span of thirty days. This brings to mind the narrative of Moses in the book of Numbers. "And they ate and were satiated, and the things which they desired he gave them, and they were not deprived of their desires. But yet the food was yet in their mouths, when the wrath of God came upon them, and killed very many of them, and brought down the elect of Israel." It is evident, therefore, that God often denies many of our petitions, not without purpose, as so many of our wants can lead to destruction. Although He may grant these requests to sinners, it serves as a safeguard so they do not accuse Him of powerlessness.

Isaac the Syrian

6th centuryChurch Father

Israel sought trivial matters, provoking the anger of God. They neglected to marvel at the awe-inspiring wonders manifested in the works of the Lord, instead pursuing the cravings of their own desires. Yet, “the wrath of God is still in their mouths, and the wrath of God is come upon them” (Psalm 77:30-31). Present your requests to God in alignment with His glory, that your worth may be exalted in His sight, and that He might rejoice in you. When one asks a king for something as insignificant as dung, they not only bring shame upon themselves through such a paltry request, revealing a lack of wisdom, but they also disrespect the king by presenting such a request. This mirrors the behavior of those who petition God for earthly benefits in their prayers.

Read more (68 words)

For consider the angels and archangels, those noble servants of the King, who observe your prayers and the nature of your petitions; they are filled with wonder and joy when they see that you, being of the earth, have set aside worldly matters to seek heavenly treasures. Conversely, they experience sorrow when they witness someone who has abandoned the pursuit of divine gifts to seek after the trivial.

Irenaeus (Klementjewsky)

18th centuryCommentator

The prophet conveys that God heeded the cries of His people, not to fulfill their whimsical desires, but to demonstrate through His actions that they undervalued His omnipotence. While it was not beyond God’s capability to conjure the birds mentioned by the prophet right in the wilderness, He chose instead to command the winds, intending for the Israelites to recognize that all creation submits to His authority, and that geographical distances do not hinder His power from swiftly reaching from east to west. In this moment, the faithless Israelites witnessed the might of God, which they disparaged, realizing that every element stands ready to respond and execute His will without hesitation.

Read more (316 words)

It is evident that God directed the winds in accordance with the location of the camps, although He could have employed other methods to deliver the birds directly among the people. When He proclaimed, “I will eat, and they will be satiated,” it serves not merely to illustrate that God provided a vast multitude of birds of prey for their feasting, but rather to highlight their desire for meat as a mere whim, rather than a genuine need for sustenance. Just as previously noted regarding the manna being given to their fill, it is similarly stated of the meat, “And they were eaten, and were filled with meat,” which vividly showcases the gluttony of the Israelites, emphasizing their unchecked desires.

Although God often promises to fulfill the desires of the faithful as a sign of His favor, here He responds differently to the corrupt yearnings of the unclean multitude. In a display of righteous anger, what He permitted revealed His displeasure. This is further explicated as it is noted that this gluttony was harmful to them. For alongside the food they consumed came the blaze of God’s wrath: while the meat was still in their mouths, the fury of God struck them down, causing the demise of their strongest men. Nevertheless, it is stated that they were not denied their cravings, indicating they were not restrained from their frivolous wishes.

Even though God’s wrath encompassed all the tribes, the Prophet highlights only the stout and prominent men, serving to illustrate God’s justice more clearly. Strong young men, relying on their might and neglecting the reverence owed to God, often presume they can act with impunity; therefore, it is unsurprising that they faced more severe punishment from God’s wrath. It was a terrifying sight to witness the downfall of such chosen and vigorous individuals; yet, the Israelites remained unmoved by this disgrace, starkly revealing their hardened hearts.

Psalter with Commentaries (Cave Monastery in Kiew)

19th centuryCommentator

This Psalm, attributed to David and rich in prophetic insight, was entrusted to Asaph, the lead singer, for the purpose of conveying understanding to all regarding the countless blessings of God Almighty bestowed upon the ungrateful descendants of the Jews. It admonishes them for their ingratitude while educating others to express gratitude for the boundless compassion of God, particularly as manifested in Christ the Lord, who believes in His name. In this psalm, David speaks as though representing Christ to the Christian faithful, urging them to pay attention to the Gospel's teachings. While the lessons of this psalm were once applicable to the Jews, they are now directed towards the followers of Christ; the old law serves as a shadow of the new covenant.

Read more (188 words)

The Savior calls upon His people to listen carefully, warning them against suffering the same demise as the earlier Jewish generations who disregarded God's commands. He instructs them to diligently examine the law of the Gospel and to absorb the prophecies from a sincere heart. Though the Jews possessed strength, they faltered in the moment of the Passion of Christ due to their lack of faith. The tribe of Ephraim, in particular, was notably unfaithful, succumbing to the idolatry of the golden calf and leading the other nine tribes astray. As a consequence of this betrayal, God stripped them of their valor; although they had been skilled archers, cowardice seized them, and they retreated in battle. They were ultimately taken captive and scattered among the Gentiles. Despite their complete surrender to worldly wisdom and refusal to repent, God showed mercy to the Jews. In His immense compassion, He chose not to annihilate them in the wilderness but instead spared and had compassion on them. Humanity, as embodied in flesh, is entwined with passions and decay. The Spirit, having departed from mankind, will not return until the second coming.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.