The Church Fathers on this verse

Psalm 44 (43):23Meaning & Commentary from the Church Fathers

Arise, why sleepest thou, O Lord? arise, and cast us not off to the end.

Douay-Rheims · Hebrew numbering, Septuagint numbering in brackets.

The Church Fathers on this verse

9 Church Fathers comment on this verse

John Chrysostom

4th centuryChurch Father

Consider the magnificence of their virtue, as the prophet states, "But for your sake they put us to death every day, counting us as sheep to be slaughtered." It is indeed commendable to remain dedicated to the service of God and not turn towards other pursuits; however, under the relentless torture of death and looming dangers each day, maintaining such profound love for Him is of even greater significance. Reflect on the magnitude of this unwavering commitment, especially as Paul highlights it in his letter to the Romans, where he recounts the numerous perils faced in the ministry (Romans 8:36). What accolades must those of the Old Testament deserve, who have achieved the standard of the exploits found in the New Testament? As Paul proclaims, "I die every day" (1 Cor.

Read more (117 words)

15:31), so too do they—not in action or experience, but within their spirits. Why do they say, "for Thy sake"? They could choose to abandon the divine statutes and find safety; yet, they have chosen to endure great suffering and uphold the fatherly traditions rather than seek peace at the expense of divine laws. "They are counted as sheep to be slaughtered," they remark, noting how readily their adversaries seek to eradicate them. This also reflects their submission. Despite being in such peril, they remain unwavering in spirit. Here, one can rightly marvel at the power of God, who safeguards those regarded as sheep for the slaughter, preventing those who face death daily from being entirely consumed.

Augustine of Hippo

5th centuryChurch Father

You may observe a man being executed, yet the reasons for his death remain a mystery to you; only God is aware of the truth behind it. The nature of the situation is concealed. Some might argue that this individual is imprisoned for the sake of Christ, serving as a witness to His name. Why is it, then, that heretics also do not proclaim the name of Christ and face death for Him? Furthermore, consider this: do you truly believe that within the universal church there have not been individuals willing to endure suffering for the sake of earthly honor? If such individuals did not exist, the apostle would not have claimed, "If I give my body to be burned, and have not charity, it profits me nothing" (1 Cor. 13:3).

Read more (95 words)

Thus, he understood that there would indeed be people who act not out of genuine love but out of pride. This reality remains hidden from us; it is known only to God, while we are unable to discern it. Only He can judge what lies within the depths of the heart. "For your sake we are killed all day long; we are counted as sheep for the slaughter." I have previously noted that the Apostle Paul cited this to encourage martyrs, so they would not lose heart amid the trials they faced for Christ's name.

Basil the Great

4th centuryChurch Father

I did not endure these trials unwillingly or under duress, the Prophet declares, but with a heart full of love and willingness I bore the burdens. Thus, I can affirm: For Thy sake we die all the day long. This sentiment mirrors the teaching of the Apostle, who also expresses a similar conviction when he asks: Who shall separate us from the love of God? Shall tribulation, or distress, or persecution, or famine, or nakedness, or peril, or sword? (Rom. 8:35)

Athanasius the Great

4th centuryChurch Father

For Your sake, we endure suffering every day. This mirrors the words that were spoken: ‘They were stoned, they were struck down, they were slain with the sword’ (Hebrews 11:37). The prophets bear the sins of the people upon themselves while also embodying their virtues, as they are united with the people as one body. Furthermore, our disbelief has placed us in such turmoil that we resemble those facing execution or sheep being led to slaughter.

Ambrose of Milan

4th centuryChurch Father

Let us delve deeper into our psalm: If we forget the name of our God and extend our hands to foreign deities, will not God take notice? (Aquila states: Will He pursue it?; Symmachus: Will He uncover it?) Moreover, it is written: For He discerns the hidden aspects of the heart. For Your sake, we are killed all day long; we are counted as sheep destined for slaughter (Psalm 43:21-23). Why is it phrased ‘God will take notice’? As though He would be unaware unless He seeks; when He discovers the forgetfulness that lingers within us, He will eradicate all remnants of it. Thus, Aquila interprets it as will pursue. For if God comprehends the hidden secrets of the heart, why would He need to search for anything?

Read more (718 words)

He perceives all that is veiled, for in the presence of God, every person's conscience is laid bare, and our thoughts may either accuse or justify us. Let us note the additional phrase in Aquila's interpretation: visions of the heart, as God perceives our innermost thoughts: all the contemplations of our hearts are exposed before Him, and the essence of our thoughts is vividly revealed in His sight. Aquila rightly expressed: In You we are brought to death, signifying that death through Christ leads to glory. Those who pass away in Christ earn the crown of holy martyrdom for His name. Should we be astonished by what is stated in this verse? We witness that God examines the secrets of the heart, and in another scripture, He is referred to as the searcher of hearts. Is it surprising that words fail to convey the magnificence of His divine essence? The apostle proclaims, “Judge not any man before the time, until the Lord come, who shall both bring to light the hidden things of darkness, and shall reveal the intentions of the heart: and then every one shall be praised of God" (1 Cor. 4:5). We frequently encounter references to spiritual darkness, often understood as sin. Does ‘hidden in darkness’ not equate to ‘concealed in the soul,’ the mysteries of the heart? They are obscured in darkness because they cannot be perceived by others; they remain unseen. Thus, when we assert that on the Day of Judgment the Lord will illuminate the hidden in darkness, it indicates that the heart of each individual will be revealed. Yet until that moment, it was known only to Christ. He understands the significance of His judgment and thus asserts, “There is nothing hidden that will not be revealed" (Matthew 10:26). Many thoughts and feelings we may withhold out of humility, keeping them within ourselves and avoiding discussion. By doing so, we adhere to heavenly guidance, ensuring that we do not appear to boast of our feelings, for voicing them could deprive us of their fruits. Additionally, there are mysteries of wisdom that Paul witnessed when he ascended to heaven. These could not be conveyed to humans, not out of envy for their benefit, but because sharing them might not serve the listener's good: the secrets of wisdom will be unveiled by the Lord in due time. Do not assume there is any inconsistency with these words found in the Gospel, as it asserts, “There is nothing hidden that has not been revealed, and nothing secret that has not been learned" (Matthew 10:26). No, this aligns well with our interpretation, as we may infer that both references pertain to the righteous. For it is written, “The Lord knows those who are His" (2 Tim. 2:19). Thus, He recognizes His own, aware of those who know God. Conversely, He does not acknowledge those who do not know God, for whoever lacks knowledge will not be recognized. God discerns what is good. He understands that which embodies the knowledge of God and comprehends the mysteries of wisdom, yet He rejects that which is marred by injustice and sin. Now let’s examine the individuals in our psalm. They do not forget to revere God, nor do they extend their hands to foreign idols, unwilling to expose their souls to them. Understand that the secrets of their heart do not bear vices but reflect the actions of the pure in spirit. They were brought to death for honoring God and lived in that state continuously, much like Paul, who declared, “I die every day for your glory" (1 Cor. 15:31). Paul indeed faced daily death in the flesh— during hunger, shipwrecks, and various afflictions— yet he did not perish entirely: while the outward man faced decay, the inward man was renewed and remained steadfast despite numerous trials. Even though his outward form waned, his inner self was rejuvenated day by day, for each person's day shines with faith and good deeds. Thus, the Apostle Paul experienced no night: he who is renewed continually exists in light. Can someone filled with the love of Christ dwell in darkness? He is unafraid of sacrifice and does not shy away from hardships. Neither persecution, famine, nor sword can sever the bond of a person united to Christ through divine love.

Theodoret of Cyrus

5th centuryChurch Father

The Maccabees, along with Mattathias, their mother, and the priest Eleazar, exemplified this principle. They were not misled by enticing words, nor did they falter in the face of executions; rather, they preserved the sanctity of the true God and detested idol worship as a detestable act. And Thou knowest these matters, O Lord, as the Prophet declared, for not only are deeds evident to Thee, but the movements of the heart as well. It is important to note that this passage refers to two parties. When it states, ‘Will not God call for these? He is the tidings of the secret heart,’ the Prophet continued, ’Because for Thy sake we die all the day long.’ This shift in pronoun appears in the Hebrew text and has been maintained by other translators.

Euthymios Zigabenos

11th centuryCommentator

By our own choice, we declare that each day we willingly die for You, Lord. Rather than joining the impious in idolatry and living in comfort, we endure hardships. As Chrysostom notes, out of our love for You and in honor of Your name, we face all adversities and stand ready to endure persecution for Your faith and commandments, like sheep being led to slaughter, proceeding with unquestioning acceptance and without resistance. Another, perhaps Nikita, remarks: You understand the very thoughts that lead us to be put to death daily for our devotion. Whoever has determined in their heart to accept death for the truth during every trial has effectively died in spirit.

Read more (88 words)

The Apostle echoes this sentiment, stating that when faced with constant persecution and deathly threats, he fortified himself to steadfastly confront each challenge, thus he truly said he died daily. Martyrs are like sheep destined for sacrifice, first as offerings to God and second, by embracing their martyrdom with humility and silence, not resisting their suffering or attempting to escape, akin to how sheep behave in slaughter. For this reason, Paul echoes these sentiments in his letter to the Romans concerning those who endure for Christ (Romans 8:36).

Irenaeus (Klementjewsky)

18th centuryCommentator

The faithful conclude their prayers by earnestly seeking God's mercy and pleading for relief from their trials. For the sake of proclaiming His name, they face daily persecution, being led like lambs to the slaughter, without resistance or compassion. They again direct their prayers to God, exclaiming, ‘Arise, why do you sleep, O Lord?’ They express that the delay of God's justice feels like slumber, and by calling for Him to arise, they yearn for His retribution. It is as if they are asking, ‘Why do you endure for so long? Why do you remain silent and overlook the multitude of injustices faced by Your servants, and how Your own name is disdained? Stand up, grant us assistance, and do not abandon us from Your divine care, lest we become estranged from You and our adversaries exult in our misfortunes.’

Psalter with Commentaries (Cave Monastery in Kiew)

19th centuryCommentator

Regarding the title, Korey is referred to as Golgotha, the location of the Throne, and the sons of Korey symbolize those who exhibit patience—those who crucify their flesh along with its passions and desires, identified as the sons of Christ (Galatians 5:24). This reasoning serves to clarify that Christ endured suffering for everyone (1 Pet. 2:21), as all are called to follow in His footsteps, sharing in His sufferings, that they may also be glorified alongside Him (2 Tim. 2:2; Rom. 8:30). To those who neglect the spiritual upbringing of their children, allowing them to revel in ungodly songs while disregarding Divine narratives: such was not the practice of the ancients.

Read more (300 words)

They devoted their lives to recounting the deeds of God, so much so that parents molded their children’s mouths into vessels of knowledge about God through these stories (Chrysostom). Christ, our God, will confront the wicked but will fortify those who place their faith in Him. You have soured humanity, rejecting me, the Jews, because of disbelief. This reflects the Mystery of the Holy Trinity: the Hand signifies God the Father, Muscle denotes God the Son, and Enlightenment represents God the Holy Spirit. The horns of the Cross of Christ cause demons to tremble at the name of Jesus. Unlike horned animals that receive natural weapons, we have been bestowed the name of Jesus Christ, a title for prayer (Theodoret). Christ is despised by demons, who are shamed by Him. The entirety of a human life on earth is marked by the glory of the eternal Heavenly Fatherland. God the Father has turned away from the Jews due to their lack of faith in Christ. Consequently, the Jews are dispersed across the globe, suffering the consequences of their disbelief, much like demons facing their own disgrace. The prophet vividly illustrates the plight of the Jews in dire terms, expressing the communal misfortunes they’ve faced. All they inflicted upon Christ is repaid to them; they reviled, and they themselves are met with scorn; they mocked, and now they are mocked in return; they shook their heads at Him, and others now shake their heads at them (Athanasius). Distance yourself from the Jews due to their disbelief in Christ. Consider the words of the holy martyrs, who suffer and die for Christ. This is the call of Adam. Slumber embodies the enduring patience of God. The righteous longed for the coming of Christ and for salvation through His cross via the Resurrection.

Cross references

Passages read together with this verse.